Lightroom to Photoshop, When to Jump?

I have just started my next Introduction to Lightroom class. With each major update, Adobe’s Lightroom keeps getting more powerful, and I love sitting around my dining room table demonstrating all the features of this remarkably capable and intuitive program.  

I have been a devoted Photoshop user for years, but for many,

Sugar Hill Lupines Remembered

Photoshop’s complexity has represented a daunting barrier to the discovery of the broad potential of the “Digital Darkroom”.   Since its initial release in 2007 Lightroom has progressed from image organization, to progressively more sophisticated editing  and outputting capabilities.  I initially came to Lightroom to help organize my 400k (now 500K) images in a more easily accessible database program, but, as I became familiar with the editing functions in the Develop Module, I stayed to do much of my global editing within the program.  I found that Lightroom’s workflow was more intuitive, it had the same functions as Photoshop’s Camera RAW and the sliders were easier to use.   So why move my images to Photoshop.

I routinely tell my students that, for many of them, and especially as they get started in image editing, Lightroom may be all they need for simple image adjustments. I probably do about 90% of my image editing in Lightroom, and the resulting images could often stand on their own, but I still routinely make the move to Photoshop before feeling that my work is truly done.  So why do I make the jump?

Complicated Selections

Lightroom allows simple localized adjustments with gradient, oval and brush tools, but Photoshop allows much more finely controlled selections which can be applied to layers affecting a full range of adjustments as well as to  image layers.  The ability to use layers is a key  strength of Photoshop and essential difference between it and Lightroom.

Focus II

Focus Stack

Comparing Images

Compare Mode

Lightroom has several ways to view and compare images, most notably, the Survey and Compare options in the Library Module’s Tool Bar.  My biggest problem comes when I have several images to compare.  This most often happens when I want to find the sharpest image among a group of captures of the same scene or, when I want to select the best images from a focus stack.  The Compare Tool allows two images to be compared side-by side at varying magnifications, but it is tedious to step through a long series of similar images to find the best.  

Survey Mode, Keene Central Square

The Survey Tool allows several images to appear in an array on the work screen, but each can only be seen in full size.  This is helpful when prominent defects are apparent, but since the images can’t be zoomed together,  the survey is not useful to make precise comparisons of sharpeners and focus.  This is where Photoshop comes to the rescue.

Photoshop Arrange, Zoomed

In Photoshop several images can be arranged in various patterns, horizontally, vertically or in grids.  The images can then be zoomed together for detailed comparison.  The windows can be locked to allow synchronized movement around all the images.  Sometimes, early in the editing process,  I will move a group of images to Photoshop for this comparison and then, when I have identified the best capture, I can remove the Photoshop versions and go back to finish work on the chosen image in Lightroom.

Compositing and Text

There's always one that needs help

 Lightroom doesn’t allow the blending of different image layers.  I can’t move heads around in group portraits or add that dragon sitting on top of the lighthouse.  

I also need to jump to Photoshop to add text to my images.

Dragon on Portland Head Light

Cleaning Up

Harrisville Library Wires

Lightroom can be used to remove dust spots and other simple distractions, but, for more complex problems,  the spot removal tool does not offer the precision of Photoshops Cloning and Healing Brushes. Also the miracle of Content Aware Fill and Move, and the Puppet Move are only available in Photoshop.

 

Complex Cloning

 

Since I am teaching Lightroom, I enjoy pushing the limits of what can be done with the program’s limited tools.  It is remarkable how much can be accomplished, but at some point, for both ease and accuracy, I have to make the jump.  For now, when it comes to seriously “punishing the pixels” Photoshop is the only way to go

Sharing

Tulip Path, Putney VT

It is important to understand that a file in Lightroom is not a finished image.  The price of nondestructive manipulations is that the image that you see in the Lightroom‘s working panel is not real.  It is still just the RAW file with a bunch of adjustments stored in the catalog, but not actually affecting the original image file.  That is why there is no “save” command in Lightroom.  To make the Lightroom image actually “real”, available for you to save, and others to see, it must be Exported into any of a number of standard formats.  Whether it is in a PSD, TIFF, JPG, PNG other other, more exotic, formats the Lightroom adjustments are burned in and the image is no longer RAW.  

Most of the time, I make this jump by moving the image for final touch-ups to Photoshop, but the Lightroom adjustment can also be applied as the file is exported to a specific image format.

Either way, before the jump, I ask myself if I have done all I can within Lightroom. When I make the move I want to know that I am leaving a pristine RAW file in my directory and a safely separate and nondestructive set of adjustments carefully archived in my Lightroom Catalog.

Printing

OK, this is an admission of my Lightroom ignorance.  I have never been able to get the best results when I try to print from Lightroom.  All the controls seem to be there, but I remain more comfortable applying my printer profiles and adjusting the resulting soft proof from within Photoshop.

 
I’m always embarrassed when I reach the point in my Introduction to Lightroom Class when I have to review the Print  Module.  The Module is powerful and intuitive.  I know I’ll get it eventually, but for me fine art printing is a whole different part of the process of image making and, for now, to get it right, I still make the jump to Photoshop.  

 
These are just a few of the reasons why I make the jump.  I am sure that there are many more.  Sometimes, when I’m happy with the image in Lightroom, and don’t have any obvious reason to move, I will still finish my work with a final examination in Photoshop. A fresh look in the context of the expanded tools of my old friend can often suggest subtle final adjustments that can make a significant difference.

Jeffrey Newcomer
partridgebrookreflections.com

Showing the Work - And Then Some

September Setting
Chesterfield, NH

Orchard Wall
Dublin, NH

From the moment that I started trying to take my photography seriously, I have believed and taught the central importance of “Showing the Work”.  Over the years I have hung my pictures in churches, banks, offices, government buildings, art fairs, galleries, coffee shops, furniture stores and almost every restaurant in the area.  Basically, if there is a public wall within the Monadnock region, my work, at some point, has, almost certainly been nailed to the plaster.

Bellows Walpole Inn

My shameless self-promotion became especially clear to me this week as I was hanging pictures, at our local Chamber of Commerce, for the Annual Keene Art Walk.  Every year the businesses along Keene’s wide main street open their windows to local artists.  For ten days in the late spring, the downtown becomes an expansive, open-air, art gallery.  It is great fun, with the chance to meet lots of new people who may not have seen my work in other venues.  Over the years I have had the opportunity to grace the windows of several downtown establishments, but I am happy to be back at the Chamber on Keene’s historic Central Square.

Sunset Lake : Bellows Walpole Inn

I had room for eight of my pictures in the Chamber’s windows, but what struck me was that I had to do a bit of scrapping to collect these images for display.  Normally this is not a problem.  Because I do my own printing, matting and framing, I have the luxury of keeping a substantial inventory of works for my shows.  I could never afford to have so many if they needed to be printed commercially, and framed by one of our local shops.  The issue is that I am currently taking the command to “show the work” to extremes. With the addition of Art Walk I now have my pictures in four different venues.  Over forty of them!  I am at serious risk of going from “show the work” to drowning the community in the work.

I guess I shouldn’t complain about the exposure, but if you want to escape my pictures, here are the places to avoid .

Bellows Walpole Inn

This is, by far, my biggest show at present.  The Inn’s restaurant and bar are lovely classics of New England ambiance and I am thrilled to have 27 of my images on their walls. I have many old favorites and five newly framed pictures.  

Reflected Spire,

 My show was set for May but has been temporarily held over.  Restaurants are favorite places to display my work, especially when I like the food.  At the Bellows Walpole Inn, I like the food.

Syd’s Furniture

Syd’s Carpet and Snooze Room is a great store near Keene’s Main Street, and behind the Keene Sentinel building.  For several years they have generously allowed the artist of

Pemiquid Light
Maine

the Monadnock Area Artist Association to hang their work on their walls. They get a beautiful and varied selection of artistic decoration and we get place to show our work surrounded by comfy chairs and couches.  I have a few pieces in the showroom on more or less permanent display, one of which won a Best in Show prize.

Keene Family YMCA

The YMCA is a great facility, offering a wide variety of programs for kids and adults.  I try to flog myself around the weight machines and aerobic equipment several times per week, but the Y has many more options including racquetball courts, a large pool and an extensive menu of classes.  Perhaps its most important asset is the friendly staff who create a relaxed family atmosphere. A few months ago, I was excited to be asked to hang some of my larger pictures on walls in the main stairwell and the exercise area.  I get annoyed when I see perfectly good blank walls in public locations.  I was please to fill a couple these spaces, that I am regularly forced to look at through sweat clouded eyes.

The Keene Art Walk

Finally. I return to the Art Walk.  Despite my thinning reserves, I am happy with the selection that I was able to assemble for the Chamber. They include one of my favorite covered bridges in the idyllic New England village of Green River Vermont, a glowing Sunflower, an evening view of the classic hill-top town center of Washington and the

Green River, Guilford Vt
Keene Chamber

Whaleback Lighthouse at dawn.  I also have a new picture of peak fall colors along the road to Roads End Farm in Chesterfield, New Hampshire.   This is one of my favorite autumn foliage images and, for the first time, I tried rendering it as a canvas gallery wrap.  I still prefer to do my own printing, but I liked the results from this lab and will be trying more on appropriate images.

Roads End Farm, Chesterfield NH
Bellow Walpole Inn

So that is my current exhibition menagerie.  From a practical perspective, I am often asked if I sell much from these shows, and

Multnomah Falls
YMCA

my answer is always the same.  I do sell occasional pieces, but that is not the primary goal of showing the work.  My most important result is to stay in the minds of my regional neighbors.  I think I have become known as a good source for quality New England images, with a special emphasis on the Monadnock Region and southern Vermont.  The hope is that, at some time in the future, when they need a gift for a friend or some images to give local flavor to a web site or brochure, my pictures will come to mind.  Also, as I have been focusing more on teaching these shows serve as graphic advertisements for my photography classes.  

Of course, beyond all the coldly practical reasons, it is just nice to release my work to the world and enjoy the moments when people seem to share the joy that I experienced when I captured these brief glimpses of the unique beauty of New England.  

I hope to see you at some of my current “venues”, but, if you can’t make it, don’t worry.  If you live in the Monadnock region you can be assured that my pictures will remain annoyingly hard to avoid.

Jeffrey Newcomer

partridgebrookreflections.com

Spring Green

Lifting Mist Chesterfielld NH

Over the last couple of weeks, I have been preoccupied with my Spring Waterfall Workshop and the preparation for my Introduction to Lightroom class.  Without realizing it, the spring color has been fading away, and it would be a tragedy if I didn’t spend at least as little time on the remarkably varied shades of green that mark this wonderful season.  While I have been scouting all the waterfalls, I have also tried to pay attention to the spring color, and I think it is time to celebrate the green.

Spring Sunset, Alyson's Orchard, Walpole, NH

I have been wandering through this spring’s images looking for those that reflect the excitement of the  exploding foliage.  As I have said many times, I feel that the spring greens populate a brief time which is comparable to the autumn color for both variety and interest.  The fall hues are gaudier but spring greens have a wonderfully warm and calming palate of colors. It is unfortunate that more “leaf peepers” don’t recognize the beauty of our “second leaf season”, but, then again, the quiet adds to the magic of the season.  Of course spring has the advantage of marking the much needed relief from the barren winter months, and perhaps most importantly, it is not immediately followed by the need to start raking.

Foral Steps, Spofford NH

So here is a collection of my images from this spring’s green, many of which I had to neglect as I focused on the waterfalls.  Falling water is the other major photographic treasure of this time of year, but as “stick season” happily  fades to a distant memory, it is time for newer life.

Check out more spring images in my Spring Green 2017 Gallery   
& in my voluminous
Spring in New England Gallery

Garwin Bloom, Wilton NH

 

Spring green always starts with the surprising promise of the first little buds, which seem to burst forth overnight. It is a time for macro photography, as the tiny shoots emerge with their delicate alien appearance.  These harbingers are not hard to find.  A simple stroll around my village yields all I need.

Tulip Path, Putney Vermont

As the leaves mature and begin to take on signs of their eventual summer morphology, I can pull back and explore the endless patterns of green.  Light and dark, and, the varying  intricate patterns of growth.  This is a time when the foliage is still fresh and not marked by insects, molds and the other inevitable ravages of the long summer.  For me, it is a time when nature’s purity can’t help but penetrate my mood with an remarkable sense of renewal.  

My Apple Blossoms, Spofford NH

Ok.  Enough of these spiritual ramblings.  Just look at the pictures!

A Favorite at Sunset

Whenever I get the opportunity, I enjoy aimlessly wandering through the spring color.  It is everywhere, but occasionally I get a chance to shoot in a special location that seems created for photography.  A couple of weeks ago I joined a group of dedicated supporters of Keene’s wonderful Colonial Theatre for a celebratory dinner.  Happily, the event was at one of my favorite farms in Keene, New Hampshire. Over the years, I have shot the farm in all seasons, weathers and light. It is in a perfect location and has been lovingly maintained. On this occasion I was able to drift away from the festivities to capture glorious spring in the fields, trees and building, all bathed in golden evening light. I wandered around the property in awe, jumping from one classic scene to another.  The bonus was that the food was great and I didn’t get infested with ticks.

In the City

Later in the season I spent an afternoon exploring the color around Keene’s downtown and the classic Old Stone Arch.  The color and detail of the architecture made a nice contrast to the soft textures of the new foliage.

Old Stone Bridge, Keene NH

Golden Hour and the Mists

Chesterfield, NH

On a number of occasions I got out in the morning to capture the warm light of the golden hour.  Warm light, especially when seen through the leaves, accentuates the greens.  Contrasting with the warm glow was the soft and mysterious light of misty spring mornings.  I always run out of the house to shoot whenever I awaken to the early morning fog.  It burns off all too quickly, but, while it lasts, the mood is magical.

Pasture Mist, Chesterfield, NH

Back to Lightroom

Sadly, but inevitably, the greens are settling into their summer hues.  There will be plenty of magic to capture this summer, but now I have to get back to my preparation for my Lightroom Class.  It is amazing that no matter how many times I present the class, it always feels like I'm starting from scratch.  I still have a couple of openings for the class which starts June 1st if you want to get a jump start on using this remarkably powerful program.

• Spring Green 2017 Gallery   
• Spring in New England Gallery

Jeffrey Newcomer

partridgebrookreflections.com

603-363-8338